Skip to content

Listen to Our Newest Podcast Episodes!

Podcasts

Homebuilders Association VancouverHomebuilders Association Vancouver
Homebuilders Association Vancouver
  • Find a Professional
  • About
    • Who We Are
      • About Us
      • Meet The Team
      • Board of Directors
      • Committees
      • Charities Supported
      • Honourary Members
    • What We Do
      • Industry Education
      • Consumer Education
      • Government Relations
      • News
      • Newsletters
    • Contact
      • General
      • Media Inquiries
      • Issue Resolution
  • Resources
    • Consumer Resources
      • Podcast: Measure Twice Cut Once
      • Design Build Blog
      • First-Time Home Buyers Resources
      • Kitchen Renovation Vancouver
      • Interior Designer Vancouver
      • Industry Links
    • Member Resources
      • Find a Career
      • HAVAN Education
      • Construction Education Resources
      • Builders’ Blog
      • Builder Licensing
      • Building Standards
      • RenoMark
  • COVID-19
  • Events
    • Consumer Events
      • Home Buying 101
      • Home Reno Show – postponed
      • Parade of Homes – Canceled. See you in 2021!
      • Coats For Kids
    • Member Events
      • Upcoming Events
      • Buildex 2020
      • Members Expo – See you in 2021!
      • Housing Awards of Excellence
      • Fall Classic Golf Tournament
      • Legends of Housing
  • Membership
    • Join Now
    • Benefits of Joining
    • Awards
    • HAVAN Heroes
    • HAVAN Spotlights
    • Committees
    • Sponsorship Opportunities
    • Affinity Program
    • Advertise With Us
    • Photo Gallery
    • Code of Ethics
    • FAQ
    • Member’s Only Page
 
Login

Join Us

  • Find a Professional
  • About
    • Who We Are
      • About Us
      • Meet The Team
      • Board of Directors
      • Committees
      • Charities Supported
      • Honourary Members
    • What We Do
      • Industry Education
      • Consumer Education
      • Government Relations
      • News
      • Newsletters
    • Contact
      • General
      • Media Inquiries
      • Issue Resolution
  • Resources
    • Consumer Resources
      • Podcast: Measure Twice Cut Once
      • Design Build Blog
      • First-Time Home Buyers Resources
      • Kitchen Renovation Vancouver
      • Interior Designer Vancouver
      • Industry Links
    • Member Resources
      • Find a Career
      • HAVAN Education
      • Construction Education Resources
      • Builders’ Blog
      • Builder Licensing
      • Building Standards
      • RenoMark
  • COVID-19
  • Events
    • Consumer Events
      • Home Buying 101
      • Home Reno Show – postponed
      • Parade of Homes – Canceled. See you in 2021!
      • Coats For Kids
    • Member Events
      • Upcoming Events
      • Buildex 2020
      • Members Expo – See you in 2021!
      • Housing Awards of Excellence
      • Fall Classic Golf Tournament
      • Legends of Housing
  • Membership
    • Join Now
    • Benefits of Joining
    • Awards
    • HAVAN Heroes
    • HAVAN Spotlights
    • Committees
    • Sponsorship Opportunities
    • Affinity Program
    • Advertise With Us
    • Photo Gallery
    • Code of Ethics
    • FAQ
    • Member’s Only Page
  • Blog, New homes, Renovating, Renovations / Renovating
  • Legal Articles

Winning the Bid – The Importance of Following Proper Tendering Procedures

Winning the Bid – The Importance of Following Proper Tendering Procedures

British Columbia’s competitive construction industry sees its fair share of intense bidding wars between contractors. To avoid the risk of underbidding, contractors may be tempted to submit their bids at the last possible second to include the latest quotes and ensure cost projections are as complete as possible. However, contractors must remember that whatever advantage they may hope to gain by doing this can be completely lost if they do not ensure their bid conforms to the specific tender procedures. In the case of True Construction Ltd. v. Kamloops (City), the B.C. Court of Appeal upheld an owner’s decision to refuse a contractor’s non-compliant bid, even though it was the lowest submitted.

FACTS
In this case, the City of Kamloops (the “City”) issued an invitation to bid on the construction of a new fire hall (the “Project”). One of the tender requirements was for contractors to include a list of subcontractors to be used at the Project in an appendix to their bid. However, the contractor (the “Contractor”) submitting the lowest bid initially failed to include the appendix containing this information. Although the Contractor later faxed the required appendix to the City, the City refused to permit faxed revisions to its bid. Ultimately, the City determined that the bid was defective. The contract for the Project went to the next-highest bidder and the Contractor sued the City for damages.

THE DECISION
The Court of Appeal agreed with the City that the Bid was not tendered correctly. The list of subcontractors was found to be critical in determining the proper party to be awarded the contract for the Project.

The Court further held that the Contractor had taken advantage of the tendering process by faxing the appendix containing its list of subcontractors after its bid was originally submitted. This resulted in an unfair advantage to the Contractor, who was able to continue negotiating its subcontracts even after its bid was submitted. Because its bid was not legally capable of acceptance without the appendix, the Contractor was able to wait until the last possible moment to determine whether the Project would be profitable before finalizing its bid. If the price of its subcontracts turned out to be too high, the Contractor could simply withhold the appendix and refuse to finalize its bid. Those contractors who submitted a binding bid including their lists of subcontractors would not have the same option to walk away if the accepted price turned out to be too high. The court refused to allow the Contractor to gain an advantage by failing to follow the material terms of the City’s tender.

In its decision, the Court focused on the need to uphold the integrity of the tendering process. Whether the Contractor actually did secure an advantage was seen as immaterial. The real issue was whether the Contractor’s practice created a potential competitive advantage and undermined the integrity of the bidding process. Ultimately, the Court found that it did and the City’s decision to exclude the non-compliant bid was vindicated.

LESSON LEARNED
When submitting a bid in a tendering context, be sure to follow all the requirements contained in the invitation to tender. Owners often reserve their contractual right to disqualify improper bids, even if they are the lowest. Even though bending the requirements of the tender might appear to create a temporary advantage, it might actually prevent you from winning the bid in the long run.

This article was written by Jay N. Spiro, lawyer, and John Wiebe, articled student, who practice in construction law with the law firm of Kuhn LLP. This article is only intended as a guide and cannot cover every situation. It is important to get legal advice for specific situations. If you have any questions or comments about this case or other construction law matters, please contact us at 604-864-8877 (Abbotsford) or 604-684-8668 (Vancouver).

Post navigation

PreviousPrevious post:Gimme Shelter (Staying Behind the Corporate Veil)NextNext post:INVESTING IN RENOVATIONS PAYS OFF IN MORE THAN DOLLARS

Related Posts

CleanBC
Rebates up to $15,000 available through CleanBC Better Homes New Construction Program
Barclay Sales Fantech
Breathe the best air with Air Excellent, Fantech and Barclay Sales
Socio Guide: HAVAN’s Event Platform
Design Inspired Hand Sanitizing Solutions
Resources to Prepare Businesses for a Second Wave
Measure Twice Cut Once
MEASURE TWICE, CUT ONCE PODCAST: LISTEN, LIKE AND SHARE TO WIN A BBQ
Our Members Speak
  • HAVAN is my ‘most valued’ association for my business and for me! I meet and learn from amazing people dedicated to the homebuilding industry. It’s an exciting professional atmosphere where we work together on common issues. Read more...

    Lynn Harrison, Harrison Marketing Resources
  • The HAVAN provides strong leadership.  HAVAN leaders are often in the news and you find their consistent presence in the media.  Read more...

    Larry Clay, President
  • “Being able to network with countless professionals throughout the construction industry is invaluable.” Read more...

    Janice Pynn, CEO
  • “The bulk of my business comes from fellow HAVAN members, and every year, my membership pays for itself–usually by February”. Read more...

    Martin Knowles, Owner, photographer
  • It is my pleasure to say our decision to recently join HAVAN has been the best marketing money we have spent in 30 years in business. Read more...

    Brian Jenkins, Owner
Featured Members

Join the Homebuilders Association Vancouver

Become a Member
Consumer Links
  • Find a Builder
  • Find a Renovator
  • Find Products/Services
  • Events
  • About Us
  • Podcast
Member Links
  • Membership
  • Industry Education
  • Events
  • Members Only
Contact Info

T: 778-565-4288
F: 778-565-4289

#1011 – 7445 132 Street,
Surrey, BC V3W 1J8
Canada

Contact Us

Proudly affiliated with

 

 

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Houzz
  • Flickr
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Podcast
Social Footer Links

Copyright © 2019 Homebuilders Association Vancouver. All rights reserved.
Serving all 23 municipalities in Metro Vancouver: Vancouver, West Vancouver, Bowen Island, Lions Bay, North Vancouver (city and district), Richmond, Burnaby, New Westminster, Coquitlam, Port Moody, Port Coquitlam, Anmore, Belcarra, Surrey, Delta, White Rock, Tsawwassen, Langley (city and township), Maple Ridge, Pitt Meadows.

Website by Red Rocket Creative Strategies

Slider images credit: Project Mint Developments, Nick Bray Architecture, TQ Construction, Designs by Katerina & Silvie